Christopher2222

MaplePrimes Activity


These are replies submitted by Christopher2222

So here's the way Mathematica sees it. 

Additional Requirements Mathematica optional *Maple required *Matlab required
Hierarchical modeling that follows real-life topology supported supported supported
Multidomain modeling supported supported supported
Drag-and-drop model design supported supported supported
Work with Modelica models supported partially supported  
Combine Modelica code with drag-and-drop design supported    
Include external C functions supported   partially supported
Biochemical pathways supported    
Electrical (analog and multiphase) supported supported partially supported
Magnetic supported supported supported
Mechanical (translational, rotational, and 3D multibody) supported supported partially supported
Signal blocks (continuous, discrete, and logical) supported supported supported
State graphs supported   supported
Thermal (heat transfer and fluid flow) supported supported partially supported
Hybrid continuous-discrete solver supported partially supported supported
Real-time solver supported   supported
Sensitivity analysis solver supported    
Initialize to steady state supported   supported
One-click plotting of any system variable supported    
Automatic 3D mechanical visualization supported supported  
Custom visualization environment Mathematica Maple Matlab
2D and 3D graphics language supported partially supported supported
Advanced 3D graphics (lighting, transparency, and more) supported partially supported supported
2D and 3D animation supported partially supported partially supported
Standard formats (.avi and .mov) supported   partially supported
Instant interactivity supported    
Analysis platform Mathematica Maple Matlab
Programmable simulation control supported supported supported
Parallelized parameter sweeps supported   partially supported
Model equation analysis supported supported  
Model equilibrium detection supported supported supported
Control systems design supported supported supported
Model calibration supported supported supported
System optimization supported supported supported
Reusable standalone simulation executable supported   supported
Interactive HTML model supported   supported

 

Of course if Maple were to do a similar comparison on it's website it would probably include things Mathematica couldn't do.  A big difference is the fact that MapleSim cannot be used without Maple where-as System Modeller doesn't need to have Mathematica installed.

 

Awesome post by the way!

On M12 the image looks mosaic like
> restart; gc();
> with(ImageTools); with(plots); with(plottools);
> im := Read("c:/Program Files/Maple 12/data/tree.jpg");
> p := Preview(im);
> op(1, p):
> q := plot3d(1, x = 0 .. 2*Pi, y = 0 .. 2*Pi, coords = spherical, style = surface, grid = [235, 354]);
> display(PLOT3D(MESH(op([1, 1], q), op([1, 4 .. -1], p)), op(2 .. -1, q)), orientation = [-120, 30]);

I think there was a way to fix it but I couldn't remember.

 

 

Anyways, there are some world maps (cylindrical projection) someone has put together on the public domain here http://www.evl.uic.edu/pape/data/Earth/  linked from this page http://vterrain.org/Imagery/WholeEarth/

For me on M12 using the spherical option gives me that mosaic look, so I used coords=cylindrical just for display purposes, nothing fancy.  Here's the cylindrical look to my image

> restart; gc();
> with(ImageTools); with(plots); with(plottools);
> im := Read("c:/Documents and Settings/Cookie Monster/My Documents/Downloads/Topography.jpg");
> p := Preview(im);
> op(1, p);

> q := plot3d(1, x = 0 .. 2*Pi, y = 0 .. 2*Pi, coords = cylindrical, style = surface, grid = [177, 354]):

> display(PLOT3D(MESH(op([1, 1], q), op([1, 4 .. -1], p)), op(2 .. -1, q)), orientation = [30, 160]);

Because it is a major version.  Similarily you can't update (update is the word you intend) from Mathematica 7 to Mathematica 8. 

If you uploaded your code some experienced maple users could probably locate why it is freezing.

I suppose you mean when zooming a graph why does the text not shrink or increase?

I suppose you mean when zooming a graph why does the text not shrink or increase?

Whoa !!  No wonder no one posted an answer here.  It is a bit confusing. 

Anyone wishing to look further into this question (I decided to search and find and found)  can follow his work in length here
http://www.cheresources.com/invision/topic/14619-shell-and-tube-condenser-design/

There had been some considerable questioning and answering before he came here to mapleprimes and maple for some help.  It is, though, an interesting read.

I was actually fooled into thinking Samir Khan had come back to visit mapleprimes with a post (a celebration ensues over some interesting possible engineering marvels with maple that will come with his return) however, the celebration was extremely short lived when I saw it was unfotunately a post from the past. 

Just trying to figure out how one would type what YC has shown without the `*` in the entry line and getting it to show up in the answer.

Was able to type it out what he shows in his worksheet on Maple16 classic, document and worksheet mode and I was unable to replicate what YC has shown (all gave the answer of 1) except using his worksheet. 

He must have copy and pasted it from somewhere and Maple hid the `*` from view.  Curious as to the reasons why.

Just trying to figure out how one would type what YC has shown without the `*` in the entry line and getting it to show up in the answer.

Was able to type it out what he shows in his worksheet on Maple16 classic, document and worksheet mode and I was unable to replicate what YC has shown (all gave the answer of 1) except using his worksheet. 

He must have copy and pasted it from somewhere and Maple hid the `*` from view.  Curious as to the reasons why.

What do I get when I buy Maple 16?  Do I get hardcopy manuals?  Does a Maple 16 personal edition still exist?

@ Alejandro Jakubi - The above intended usage for dual worksheets is for comparison purposes.  Opening a new kernel and trying to open the already opened worksheet redirects me to the already opened worksheet.  I suppose I'll just save the same worksheet with two different names.

I still hear that Maple is not strong in numerics - however I find it very much adequate although others will probably disagree, and for that reason I pose a Maple 17 wish ... stronger numerics for Maple ... 

One can not measure the quality of a website accurately depending on the definition of quality being used.  The values obtained are objectionable especially if they are based on activity.  The word quality is also objectionable - quality as in content / layout or quality as in good connection, speed of information delivery etc...

I restarted and achieved the same result but if I do some other operation in the midst or just after restart the value changes slightly. 

For example, I first changed epsilon and sigma to rational values  epsilon:=convert(epsilon,rational) etc.. and of course I should observe a slight change  685.116351816730684 as you can see more decimal places have changed value. 

I also get different values if I simply restart; by itself or restart; gc():  different again if I went restart; with(plots):

Not really sure why adding with(plots) would affect the value.

First 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 Last Page 94 of 155